Yes! Your lender can let you sell your house for less than you owe. It’s called a short sale. The lender approves the sale and agrees to accept less than the full mortgage payoff from the sale proceeds.
If we were sitting at your kitchen table, I’d explain it this way. If the house can’t bring in enough to pay off the loan, the lender may take a loss either way. The question for the lender is how much it expects to recover from a sale now compared with what it expects to recover by going through foreclosure. See the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s explanation of short sales.
A qualified buyer’s offer gives the lender a price and a closing plan it can evaluate today. With foreclosure, the lender may spend more time and money on court costs, attorney fees, and the auction. If the lender ends up owning the house, it may also have to secure it, keep it up, and put it back on the market. Meanwhile, the home’s condition or market value could change.
That’s why a lender may approve a sale at a price supported by the local market and allow customary Realtor commissions and other approved closing costs to come out of the proceeds. Those costs help get the sale closed. The lender looks at how much it would actually receive after those costs. See Fannie Mae’s servicing guidance for an example of allowable short sale costs.
Suppose your mortgage payoff is $230,000, and we bring the lender a $210,000 offer that reflects what the house is worth in its current condition. After $12,000 in approved selling costs, the lender would receive $198,000. If it estimates it would recover $185,000 after going through foreclosure and accounting for its costs, the short sale could bring it $13,000 more. These numbers are illustrative. The lender makes its decision using its own figures and the rules that apply to your loan.
I’d start by looking at recent comparable sales and estimating what your Louisville-area home could sell for in its current condition. Then we’d compare what’s left after selling costs with your mortgage payoff and anything else that needs to be paid at closing. If the proceeds can cover everything, we can look at a regular sale. If there’s a shortfall you can’t cover, I can market the house, help find a buyer, and submit the offer and estimated closing figures to the mortgage company with your authorization.
I’d also help you review the written approval with the closing team. One question I’d want answered in writing is whether the lender will forgive the unpaid balance after closing. If there’s already a foreclosure sale date, tell me right away so we can address the timing and confirm directly whether any postponement has been granted.
Call David Halpern at (502) 664-7827. If your house is in Louisville or the surrounding Kentucky area, have your latest mortgage statement and any notices handy. We can go over what you owe, what the house might sell for, and whether asking your lender to approve a short sale makes sense.