Contractor Problems Making It Hard to Pay Your Mortgage?

You hired a contractor to fix a problem with your house. Now you may have paid for work that has to be redone, or the contractor took a large deposit and never showed up. The original repair still needs attention, the money you set aside is gone, and the mortgage is still due.

If we were sitting at your kitchen table, I’d ask what you’ve paid, what still needs to be done, and whether you’re already behind on the mortgage. From there, we can look at what it might cost to finish the work and what the house could sell for as it stands.

What’s happening in my situation?

The contractor did poor work, and now the house may be worth less. Say you paid to fix a leak, but water is still getting in and has damaged the ceiling below. A second contractor may have to undo some of the work before making the repair. You’re facing another bill, and buyers who see the damage may offer less because of what they expect to spend fixing it.

The contractor took a large advance and never showed up. You may have used savings that were also your backup for the mortgage. Now you have to find another contractor and come up with another deposit to get the original repair done. If you borrowed the money through a home equity line of credit, that payment may also be due even though the work never started.

The contractor started and left the job unfinished. A torn-out kitchen or an unfinished bathroom can make the house harder to live in and harder to sell. If you’re paying to finish the work, making payments on a renovation loan, or temporarily living elsewhere, there may be less money left for the mortgage. If missed mortgage payments continue, foreclosure can become a risk while the contractor dispute is still unresolved. See the CFPB’s guide to getting mortgage help.

What would I look at first?

I’d review the latest mortgage statement and any past-due notices with you. If you borrowed against the house to pay for the work, I’d ask for that loan statement too. If you’ve been served with foreclosure papers or received a sale notice, tell me right away and seek legal help promptly about any deadlines.

Then I’d look at how the house might sell in its current condition. If you have an independent repair estimate, we can compare the cost of correcting or finishing the work with what it might add to the sale price. That can help you decide whether putting more money into the house makes sense.

You can be behind on payments and still have enough equity for a regular sale. I’d compare what the house might sell for, after selling costs, with the mortgage payoff and any other amounts that must be paid at closing. If the amount available for the mortgage falls short and you can’t cover the difference, we can explore a short sale, where the lender approves the sale and agrees to accept less than the full mortgage payoff. Read the CFPB’s explanation of short sales.

What would I handle if you decide to sell?

If selling in the house’s current condition makes sense, I’ll help you price and market it, describe the condition accurately, and compare what each offer could leave you after costs. If a contractor claims you still owe money or says a lien has been filed, I can coordinate with your attorney and closing team to find out how that may affect the sale.

If you need the lender to consider a short sale, I can help prepare the paperwork, submit the buyer’s offer with your authorization, and keep you informed during the review.

What to do today

  1. Keep the contract, proof of payment, photos, and messages. Save any written repair estimates you receive. If you believe the contractor took your money without intending to do the work, you can ask the Kentucky Attorney General’s office about filing a consumer complaint. Kentucky consumer complaint information.

  2. Call your mortgage servicer if you’re behind or expect to miss a payment. Ask what help may be available while you sort out the repair or dispute.

  3. Call David Halpern at (502) 664-7827. If the house is in Louisville or the surrounding Kentucky area, tell me what happened. We can look at what the house might sell for today and whether a regular sale or a short sale is worth exploring.